Verbal vs. written contracts

Although verbal contracts are binding under South African law, it is often important, and in some circumstances necessary, to put something in writing.

Verbal vs. written contracts for conveyancing

Is a verbal agreement legally binding? Although verbal contracts are binding under South African law, it is often important, and in some circumstances necessary, to put something in writing.

When is a verbal agreements legally binding? Verbal contracts have their place in certain situations and are both simple and convenient. However, while binding, verbal contracts are often difficult and complicated to enforce in a legal dispute. This is because there is no objective and clear record of the agreement details, and the specific terms are typically difficult to ascertain. This becomes an issue if there is disagreement between the parties to such a contract, and identifying an accurate solution or remedy can be a difficult and lengthy process.

As a result, legal professionals always recommend creating a clear and concise written contract that lays out all the relevant terms to an agreement. Not only does this provide clarity for all parties to the contract regarding the rights and responsibilities of each party, but in the event of a disagreement, it offers useful information and guidance to legal representatives to ensure a fair and smooth resolution.

When it comes to a lease agreement, a written contract is strongly recommended as it provides details of important terms such as the monthly rental amount, the required notice period as well as the condition of the property and maintenance requirements from both landlord and tenant. It is common for disputes to arise as to whose responsibility it is to manage certain expenses and certain obligations. Having a written contract for lease agreements simply removes room for error and clearly lays out the details for all parties to refer to when needed.

For the sale of immovable property, a written contract is a legal requirement as set out in the Alienation of Land Act (68 of 1981). It is not hard to understand why this requirement exists for such high-value transactions. An offer to purchase, which constitutes the sale agreement once signed by both buyer and seller, sets out all the details from sale price and occupation date to fittings and fixtures that form part of the sale as well as certain conditions that have to be met in order for the sale to be valid.

It is also good practice to have a disclosure document as part of the sale agreement which details the condition of the property to eliminate any disputes that may arise as to maintenance required from the seller post sale. It would simply be far too complicated to manage such an agreement in verbal terms and would allow endless opportunities for disagreement around a highly valuable commodity.

As such, while the verbal contract remains an appropriate agreement in certain circumstances, for the sale of immovable property, a written contract is an essential criterion under South African law.

Recommended for you

What Happens To The Ownership Of My Property When I Get Married
Contractual Matters

Customary marriages and ownership of immovable property[post_view before=""]

Recognition of customary marriages in South Africa has undergone several shifts over the years through the implementation of new legislation. This has impacted not only the legal status of the parties to a customary marriage but also their ownership of and rights to matrimonial property.

Read More
My name has changed - what happens to my property’s title deed?
Contractual Matters

Rules Board Regulates Non-litigious Fees[post_view before=""]

The introduction of the Legal Practice Act 28 of 2014 has led to several changes in the juridical space, including one related to non-litigious fees – fees charged by attorneys for services that do not constitute litigation and are not finalised in court.

Read More
My name has changed - what happens to my property’s title deed?
Contractual Matters

Corporate actions and resolutions[post_view before=""]

In South Africa, the business and affairs of a company must be managed by its board of directors. As such, the board is responsible for the daily corporate and commercial affairs of the company.

Read More
Minors and immovable property
Contractual Matters

Defunct Homeowners Associations and Consents to Transfer[post_view before=""]

Title deeds of cluster developments commonly contain a condition which states that alienation or transfer of a property by the owner is not allowed unless consent from the Homeowners Association (HOA) is provided. Usually inserted by the relevant local authority when approving the cluster development, this type of condition also confirms that all subsequent owners of the property automatically become members of the HOA.

Read More
The difference between movable and immovable property
Contractual Matters

The conveyancing process explained[post_view before=""]

The conveyancing process starts with a signed Offer to Purchase and ends with the property being registered in the Deeds Office. But, there are numerous steps that need to be completed in between. Here’s a look at how the process unfolds.

Read More

Need more Snymans content?

Sign up for our monthly newsletter.

Verbal vs. written contracts

Although verbal contracts are binding under South African law, it is often important, and in some circumstances necessary, to put something in writing.

Verbal vs. written contracts for conveyancing

Is a verbal agreement legally binding? Although verbal contracts are binding under South African law, it is often important, and in some circumstances necessary, to put something in writing.

When is a verbal agreements legally binding? Verbal contracts have their place in certain situations and are both simple and convenient. However, while binding, verbal contracts are often difficult and complicated to enforce in a legal dispute. This is because there is no objective and clear record of the agreement details, and the specific terms are typically difficult to ascertain. This becomes an issue if there is disagreement between the parties to such a contract, and identifying an accurate solution or remedy can be a difficult and lengthy process.

As a result, legal professionals always recommend creating a clear and concise written contract that lays out all the relevant terms to an agreement. Not only does this provide clarity for all parties to the contract regarding the rights and responsibilities of each party, but in the event of a disagreement, it offers useful information and guidance to legal representatives to ensure a fair and smooth resolution.

When it comes to a lease agreement, a written contract is strongly recommended as it provides details of important terms such as the monthly rental amount, the required notice period as well as the condition of the property and maintenance requirements from both landlord and tenant. It is common for disputes to arise as to whose responsibility it is to manage certain expenses and certain obligations. Having a written contract for lease agreements simply removes room for error and clearly lays out the details for all parties to refer to when needed.

For the sale of immovable property, a written contract is a legal requirement as set out in the Alienation of Land Act (68 of 1981). It is not hard to understand why this requirement exists for such high-value transactions. An offer to purchase, which constitutes the sale agreement once signed by both buyer and seller, sets out all the details from sale price and occupation date to fittings and fixtures that form part of the sale as well as certain conditions that have to be met in order for the sale to be valid.

It is also good practice to have a disclosure document as part of the sale agreement which details the condition of the property to eliminate any disputes that may arise as to maintenance required from the seller post sale. It would simply be far too complicated to manage such an agreement in verbal terms and would allow endless opportunities for disagreement around a highly valuable commodity.

As such, while the verbal contract remains an appropriate agreement in certain circumstances, for the sale of immovable property, a written contract is an essential criterion under South African law.