He Said, She Said

The most common causes of Estate Agent commission disputes and how to avoid them.

Divorce Guidelines In & Out of Community of Property

Estate Agent commission, a fee that is due to the agent in exchange for the successful brokerage of a property sale, can be the cause of many disagreements if not clearly dealt with in the mandate or handled appropriately.

As part of a typical property sale, the seller is responsible for paying the Estate Agent commission which is calculated as a percentage of the sale price; this is the fee for finding a willing buyer and is due and payable to the Estate Agent once the offer to purchase has been signed by both the buyer and seller.

As with many elements in the property transfer process, there are potential pitfalls, and knowing what these are in advance can help prevent them becoming problematic later on.

For example, should there be more than one Estate Agent appointed to market the property, there is the potential for disagreements to arise when there are multiple offers received through different agents. Most importantly, once an unconditional offer to purchase has been accepted by the seller the commission becomes due to the agent that effectively caused the sale to be concluded. If a seller subsequently accepts another (possibly more lucrative) unconditional offer, the seller may be liable for commission on both the offer that results in the property transfer, as well as the offer initially accepted but subsequently cancelled.

Another situation which can result in complications is when the contract of sale is cancelled due to a breach by one of the parties. Although in the typical scenario, the seller is liable for the Estate Agent commission, in this case, it is the person who is in breach of the contract who will be held liable for commission.

It is always best to preempt such situations. To avoid confusion and potential disagreements, both buyers and sellers should pay close attention to the terms contained in the offer to purchase. In addition, the seller should be made aware upfront by the Estate Agent of what to expect through the sale process, particularly when working with multiple Estate Agents.

Should a dispute occur, however, litigation should be considered a last resort, as it can be a lengthy and costly process. Instead, it is always best to attempt to resolve this between the parties concerned, and where necessary with the facilitation of the relevant conveyancing attorneys.

Follow Snymans on Facebook for more legal advice, information and news about property.

Recommended for you

Properties using borehole water must display a sign
Contractual Matters

A Crucial Victory for Water Rights[post_view before=""]

Agriculture is one of the most important sectors of the global economy, and it relies heavily on water resources for crop production. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), agricultural water usage accounts for about 70% of the world’s freshwater withdrawals.

Read More
Your Trusted Partner in Residential and Commercial Property Transfers
Contractual Matters

The Agent’s Responsibility to the Tenant, Buyer and Seller When Selling a Property with a Tenant in It.[post_view before=""]

When selling a property with a tenant, the agent must disclose the tenant and lease agreement to the buyer to avoid disputes or the tenant becoming a squatter. The lease agreement takes precedence over the agreement of sale during its duration.

Read More
Your Trusted Partner in Residential and Commercial Property Transfers
Contractual Matters

The Validity of Wills – a Look at Formalities[post_view before=""]

A Testament/Will is a document where a person states their last wishes and what must happen with their estate after their death. If a person dies without leaving a Will, his/her estate will be administered in terms of the “Intestate Succession Act”. This Act provides for rules by which assets are distributed to relatives.

Read More
Curatorship - what does it mean to be put under curatorship?
Contractual Matters

Inheritance of surviving opposite sex life partners[post_view before=""]

In light of the recent development in Bwanya v Master of the High Court, opposite-sex life partners are now entitled to inherit in terms of the Intestate Succession Act, which was once a benefit exclusively awarded to partners in a same-sex life partnership.

Read More
Your Trusted Partner in Residential and Commercial Property Transfers
Contractual Matters

Platinum Property Enterprise (Pty) Ltd / McShane and The Registrar of Deeds (Case no: 11611/2022)[post_view before=""]

In this case, Platinum Property, the Purchaser, being a company, entered into an agreement of sale with the Seller, being a 93-year-old lady. Platinum took this seller to Court to stop her from transferring the property to another second Purchaser and further to order her to sign their transfer documents. The main issue before the Court was the issue of repudiation and the manner in which the Conveyancer dealt with the transaction.

Read More

Need more Snymans content?

Sign up for our monthly newsletter.

He Said, She Said

The most common causes of Estate Agent commission disputes and how to avoid them.

Divorce Guidelines In & Out of Community of Property

Estate Agent commission, a fee that is due to the agent in exchange for the successful brokerage of a property sale, can be the cause of many disagreements if not clearly dealt with in the mandate or handled appropriately.

As part of a typical property sale, the seller is responsible for paying the Estate Agent commission which is calculated as a percentage of the sale price; this is the fee for finding a willing buyer and is due and payable to the Estate Agent once the offer to purchase has been signed by both the buyer and seller.

As with many elements in the property transfer process, there are potential pitfalls, and knowing what these are in advance can help prevent them becoming problematic later on.

For example, should there be more than one Estate Agent appointed to market the property, there is the potential for disagreements to arise when there are multiple offers received through different agents. Most importantly, once an unconditional offer to purchase has been accepted by the seller the commission becomes due to the agent that effectively caused the sale to be concluded. If a seller subsequently accepts another (possibly more lucrative) unconditional offer, the seller may be liable for commission on both the offer that results in the property transfer, as well as the offer initially accepted but subsequently cancelled.

Another situation which can result in complications is when the contract of sale is cancelled due to a breach by one of the parties. Although in the typical scenario, the seller is liable for the Estate Agent commission, in this case, it is the person who is in breach of the contract who will be held liable for commission.

It is always best to preempt such situations. To avoid confusion and potential disagreements, both buyers and sellers should pay close attention to the terms contained in the offer to purchase. In addition, the seller should be made aware upfront by the Estate Agent of what to expect through the sale process, particularly when working with multiple Estate Agents.

Should a dispute occur, however, litigation should be considered a last resort, as it can be a lengthy and costly process. Instead, it is always best to attempt to resolve this between the parties concerned, and where necessary with the facilitation of the relevant conveyancing attorneys.

Follow Snymans on Facebook for more legal advice, information and news about property.